The Wheel vs. Just Selling Covered Calls
Compare the full Wheel strategy with standalone covered calls. Income potential, flexibility, capital usage, and which approach generates better returns.
We're recording short 2-3 minute video explainers for every lesson. The full written guide is ready below. Bookmark this page — the video will appear right here when it's ready.
Quick Overview
Covered calls generate income on shares you already own. The Wheel is a complete system that adds a cash-secured put phase before the covered call phase. The Wheel generates income whether you own shares or not, while covered calls only work when you hold the stock.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Covered Calls Only | The Wheel Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Phases | One (sell calls on shares owned) | Two (sell puts, then sell calls) |
| Income when not holding shares | No | Yes (put selling phase) |
| Entry method | Buy shares at market price | Get assigned at a discount via puts |
| Capital usage | 100% in shares | Alternates between cash and shares |
| Flexibility | Limited to owned stocks | Works on any optionable stock |
| Income consistency | Only when holding shares | Continuous — always selling premium |
| Effective cost basis | Stock price minus premiums | Lower — puts reduce basis before owning |
When Covered Calls Alone Are Better
- You already own shares and want to hold them. If you own AAPL at $50 from years ago, you do not need the put phase. Just sell calls.
- You are a long-term investor adding income. Buy and hold investors who want extra yield on existing positions.
- You do not want to deal with assignment. The put phase introduces assignment mechanics. If you want simplicity, just sell calls.
- You own dividend stocks. Covered calls on dividend stocks generate both premium and dividend income. The Wheel does not capture dividends during the cash phase.
- Tax considerations. If selling shares triggers large capital gains, you might prefer to keep your shares and just sell calls rather than cycle through the Wheel.
When the Wheel is Better
- You are starting fresh. The Wheel lets you enter a stock position at a discount through the put-selling phase.
- You want income at every stage. Whether you hold cash or shares, you are always collecting premium.
- You want a lower cost basis. By the time you get assigned on a put, you have already collected put premiums that lower your effective purchase price. Then you collect covered call premiums on top.
- You want a systematic approach. The Wheel gives you a clear set of rules: sell puts until assigned, sell calls until called away, repeat.
- You are focused on options income, not stock appreciation. The Wheel treats the stock as a vehicle for premium, not a long-term holding.
Income Comparison Example
Stock XYZ at $100. Both strategies start with $10,000.
Covered calls only:
- Buy 100 shares at $100 ($10,000)
- Sell $105 call monthly for ~$1.50 ($150/month)
- Annual income estimate: ~$1,800 (18% on $10,000)
The Wheel:
- Month 1-3: Sell $95 puts for ~$1.50/month. Not assigned. Collect $450.
- Month 4: Assigned at $95. Effective cost: $95 - $4.50 (cumulative puts) = $90.50.
- Month 5-8: Sell $100 calls for ~$1.50/month. Collect $600.
- Month 8: Called away at $100. Stock profit: $100 - $95 = $5/share ($500).
- Total income: $450 (puts) + $600 (calls) + $500 (stock gain) = $1,550 in 8 months.
- Annualized: ~$2,325 (23.3% on $10,000)
The Wheel generates more income because it collects premium during the waiting period before buying shares.
The Downside Risk
Both strategies have the same downside risk: the stock can drop significantly.
Covered calls: You own shares. If the stock drops 30%, you lose $3,000 minus whatever premiums you collected.
The Wheel: You get assigned shares via the put. If the stock drops 30%, you own it at your put strike minus collected premium. The damage is similar, but your effective cost basis may be lower.
Neither strategy protects you from a major crash. The key risk management tool in both cases is picking quality stocks you want to own.
Verdict
If you already own shares you plan to hold long-term, covered calls are simpler and perfectly effective. If you are building positions from scratch and want to maximize income at every stage, the Wheel is superior. The Wheel generates 20-30% more total income over time because you are earning premium during both the entry phase (puts) and the holding phase (calls). For new options income traders, the Wheel is the better framework to adopt from the start.
Ready to go deeper? Check out our free courses and strategy guides.
Free Courses Strategies Dictionary